Sunday, May 15, 2011

Does a deep knowledge of art history enable you to critique art more adequately?

I do not believe that in order to have a deep understanding of art you have to know the history of it. I think if you know to much about the history of something then you set up expectations, ones that if not met could make your emotional response to the art piece less meaningful than if you would have see it without the prior knowledge. For example when a trained dancer of 12 years goes to see a performance at the Boston Opera House. Let say the performance is the Nutcracker,one of the biggest shows of the whole year. This specific dancer has already, through training and the knowledge they have of dance, set up expectations about what the performance overall should be like. They have set standards that the performance must reach in order to be considered a "good" work of performance art.This prior knowledge inhibits the viewer form experiencing what the performance truly has to offer the audience, therefore they may have somewhat of a skewed view on what it truly is. Although this is true,  I do believe that in order to critique something then you should have some prior knowledge on the subject. 

"When is art?" a good or bad way to critique a work of art?

In my opinion Goodman’s “when is art” instead of “what is art" is a good way to view pieces of art due to the fact that he provides a set of standards in which one can see when an object becomes a piece of art. I completely agree that a work of art is seen as such when it is displayed in a certain way, for example one would not see a painting as a work of art if it were being used as a floor mat, it would most likely be seen as a work of art when it is displayed in a more formal setting such as a museum. Also I think in some sense it is true that objects are made into works of art due to the fact that we treat them in a certain way. For example if the 
Mona Lisa was not displayed in a very popular,museum surrounded by a countless number of security guards, it probably would not be seen as such a valuable art piece. I think the question when does an object become a work of art is a more easily answered question the defining what art truly is. Defining are sets a concrete definition and set of standards that a work must follow in order to be considered a work of art, unlike when one looks as when something is seen as a work of art. (it allows more room for interpretation)

"When is art?" rather than "what is art?"

Nelson Goodman states that the question within the philosophy of art is not “what is art”, but “when does an object become a work of art”. His view is based on formalism, a view that basically states that everything necessary within a work of art is contained within it. Meaning that the back round of the painting, the life of the artist, as well as the reasons for which the work of art was created is not considered to be significant when judging the quality of a piece of artwork. According to Goodman in order for an object to be seen as a work of art it must be able to function as a symbol in some contexts but not in others.  For example a piece painting is seen as a work of art when it is hanging in a museum but when it is used to replace a broken window then it is not seen as a piece of art. Therefore according to Goodman an object becomes a work of art when it has five specific characteristics. (works of art must function symbolically, features of the symbol are significant, exemplification, a symbol must perform a variety of different functions.) Goodman states that works of art are made into works of art because we approach them in a unique way that makes them more significant then other objects. 

Why Hume's views on art are biased

Hume's  idea although well thought out, seemed to be quite biased in the sense that it excluded many people who would be able to give a very well thought out criticism on what a good work of art is and what is not. The “distractions” he says that inhibit a persons ability to be a qualified judge are things that most people in this world deal with on a daily basis. For example the "distraction" of being young and in love. One's age has no way of interfering with how one perceives a piece of art as well as how one relates to a work of art. As well as being in love, the feelings you have towards another person can no way inhibit your ability to look at a work of art an appreciate it, or reject it completely. No one is able to succeed in being free of all distractions, there will always be something that will be in the back of their minds that may or may not affect their personal views on things. Therefore in some sense no one is really qualified to judge art based on his theory.  

Why I agree with Weitz views on defining art, or not defining it.

Weitz theory that art is indefinable is something that I strongly agree with. I believe that constant change of the art world makes it impossible to set any standards in which art can be defined by.  If one does set standards based on traditional views, it is very likely that many art forms would be excluded for example the art form of tattooing, as well as the culinary arts. Weitz theory often lead one to believe that potentially there can never truly be a solid definition of art. In my opinion, I think that their are a set of standards that one must follow in order to critique what art is. But I believe those set of standards are all individual. There are no one set of standards that is universally agreed upon, and that is used to critique art. Truly all there is, is one's own perception of the piece of work as well as one's emotional response and connection. Overall I think that Weitz is a great starting of point that on can look at if one is against writing a definition of art.  

Hume views on how to define art

Hume within his work “Art as Object of Taste” is not trying to create a definition, but is trying to see if one can find a set of objective standards in which one can use in order to criticize how good a work of art truly is.  He presents an antinomy, an antinomy is defined as a pair of ideas, each with a claim on truth but seemingly mutually irreconcilable. He states that the first idea of this antinomy is that people claim that they can make critical judgments about the quality of a work of art, while the other idea within this antinomy is that it is merely taste that can decide whether a work of art affects one’s “sentiments”.  He states that there can be no objective standards when judging a work of art, he also says that there are certain features within works of art that please all human beings. Since there are certain features that make a work of art pleasurable for all human beings therefore there will be a sort of universal agreement that a work of art would be more beautiful than another. Hume makes it known although there is universal agreement on some works of art, there is bound to be disagreement on how aesthetically pleasing a work of art can be. He accounts for these people who disagree as people who have a sort of psychological impairment that inhibits them from being able to adequately place judgments on a work of art. For example he says that one must ignore those who are influenced by their culture, being self absorbed, being in a state of intoxication, being sick, or even being young and in love.  He believes these things are “distractions” that do not allow people to create good judgments on about art. In order for someone to be able to pass a good judgment on art they must be clear of all distractions. 

Why "openess" makes art impossible to define

Weitz  believed that art can not truly be defined. He states that overtime art keeps changing and evolving, creating new genres that overpass the prior views of what art is. He believes that art should be classified on the basis of ones understanding of the piece of work and its resemblance to the tradition views of what art is. Therefore creating the view that art can not truly be defined, due to the fact that it is constantly evolving. Weitz says that’s art’s “openness” makes a definition impossible because art is constantly changing and evolving. As he says within his work “Art as Indefinable”, “What I am arguing, then, is that the very expansive, adventurous character of art, its ever present changes and novel creations, makes it logically impossible to ensure any set of defining properties.” What he means by this is that art constantly is creating new categories and breaking the traditional ideas of what art actually should be therefore making it impossible to create an exact set of rules in which art can be compared to and defined by.